There is an island inhabited by two tribes. The natives of one tribe always tell the truth and the natives of the other tribe always lie.
On a recent trip, a visitor was confronted by three natives, but he couldn't tell which tribe they were from. See if you can tell whether they are liars or truth-tellers from the following statements:
"Oh, we're all liars," said the first native.
"Just one of us is a truth-teller," claimed the second of the three.
The third native did not speak.
The first native was a liar, the second was a truth-teller, and the third was a liar.
If the first native was telling the truth, then there is a problem with his statement, "we are all liars." So, he must be a liar. That means that his statement is false, and there must be at least one person telling the truth.
If the second native is a liar, then either there are two people telling the truth or none. But we
know that they can't all be liars, and there can't be two truth-tellers since the first one is
known to be a liar.
Hence, the second native is telling the truth, and that means he is the only truth-teller.
So the third native is a liar (even though he didn't speak).
1. K. Sengupta | Calcutta, INDIA |
2. John Funk | Ventura, California |
3. Les Walker | Ventura, California |
4. Courtney Bouton | ---------- |
5. James Alarie | University of Michigan -- Flint Flint, Michigan |
6. Clint Lamb | Mountain View High School, Mountain View, Wyoming |
7. Taiya Cheney | Mountain View High School, Mountain View, Wyoming |
8. Katie Woody | Mountain View High School, Mountain View, Wyoming |
9. Chris Maldonado | Mountain View High School, Mountain View, Wyoming |
10. Zach Williamson | Mountain View High School, Mountain View, Wyoming |
11. Scott Woody | Mountain View High School, Mountain View, Wyoming |
12. JoAnn Reynolds | Spring Hill, Florida |
13. Jaci Egley | Mountain View High School, Mountain View, Wyoming |
14. Shay Murray | Mountain View High School, Mountain View, Wyoming |
15. Wynston Anglen | Mountain View High School, Mountain View, Wyoming |
16. Chelsea Brunski | Mountain View High School, Mountain View, Wyoming |
17. Halie Gardner | Mountain View High School, Mountain View, Wyoming |