MONSTER COSTUME PARTY — Answer Key
The fourth monster to arrive didn't bring apples (2)
or the trivia game (4); he brought either CDs or
pumpkins. Frankenstein didn't bring CDs (3) or
pumpkins (5), so he didn't arrive fourth. The
fourth arrival wasn't the Creature (1) or Wolfman
(2), so the Thing arrived fourth. The third monster
to arrive wasn't Wolfman (2) or Frankenstein (3);
he was the Creature. The second arrival was
dressed as Papa Smurf and the Thing brought
pumpkins (1). The Thing, who arrived fourth with
the pumpkins, must be mentioned in clue 3, so he
wore the Peter Cottontail costume (3). The
monster dressed as Tinker Bell didn't arrive first
(2), so he was third; by elimination, the monster
in the Cinderella costume arrived first. The
monster who brought apples arrived second (2).
Wolfman arrived first (2), and, by elimination,
Frankenstein arrived second. The Creature, who
was third, didn't bring CDs (3); he brought the
trivia game, and, by elimination, the Wolfman
brought the CDs.
In summary:
1st Wolfman Cinderella CDs
2nd Frankenstein Papa Smurf apples
3rd Creature Tinker Bell trivia game
4th Thing Peter Cottontail pumpkins